Korean Medical Treatment Including Miniscalpel Acupuncture for Patients After Rotator Cuff Tear Surgery: A Report of Two Cases

Article information

J Acupunct Res. 2019;36(3):166-171

Publication date (electronic) : 2019 August 23

doi : https://doi.org/10.13045/jar.2019.00129

Su Gyeong Kim¹, Eun Jin Park¹, Jae Eun Lim¹, Hyun Jeong Do¹, Jeong Yoon Kim², Sung Woo Cho³, Hyun Min Yoon¹, Cheol Hong Kim^1,

¹Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion Meridian and Acupoint, College of Korean Medicine, Dong-Eui University, Busan, Korea

²Department of Ophthalmology, Otolaryngology and Dermatology, Daejeon Jaseng Hospital of Korean Medicine, Daejeon, Korea

³Department of Oriental Rehabilitation, College of Korean Medicine, Dong-Eui University, Busan, Korea

*Corresponding author. Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion Meridian and Acupoint, College of Korean Medicine, Dong-Eui University, Busan, Korea E-mail: kmdkch@hanmail.net

Received 2019 June 11; Revised 2019 July 22; Accepted 2019 August 5.

Abstract

Introduction

The rotator cuff consists of four muscles; the supraspinatus, infraspinatus, subscapularis, andteres minor. The humeral head is covered by muscles, which rotate the arm and stabilize the humeral head in the joint [1].

Rotator cuff tear (RCT) is a common injury that is responsible for 50% of shoulder joint pain, and usually occurs in individuals aged 40 years or more. Most patients have a history of traumatic damage or repetitive overuse of the muscles [2]. RCT symptoms are shoulder pain and restriction of movement of the shoulder joint. The pain worsens in the night time, and active movement is restricted, whereas passive movement is normal [1]. There are conservative and surgical treatments for RCT.

Surgical treatment is considered for RCT either when there has been no improvement after 3-6 months using conservative treatment, or depending on the degree of the tear and motion disorder. After surgical reatment, management with braces and rehabilitation is required for several months to restore normal shoulder function. In addition, shoulder pain and joint stiffness are often reported despite successful surgery [3,4]. The studies of surgical methods which focus on the better clinical outcome and a low re-rupture rate have been reported. However, treatment for patients with complications such as shoulder pain and joint stiffness after RCT surgery is insufficient [5,6].

In Korean medical treatment, various treatments such as herbal medicine, acupuncture, pharmacopuncture, and moxibustion, have been reported in patients after RCT surgery [3,7]. However, reports on miniscalpel acupuncture are scarce.

It has been reported that miniscalpel acupuncture has a better outcome on musculoskeletal pain compared with regular acupuncture treatment [6,7]. It can recover the original kinetic state, and promote blood circulation to the lesionby peeling the chronically damaged soft tissue of the muscles, tendon sheath, and ligament [10].

Here, we report the clinical effects of miniscalpel acupuncture, acupuncture and herbal medicine in 2 patients who visited the Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Dong-Eui University Korean Medicine Hospital for shoulder pain and range of movement (ROM) restriction after RCT surgery.

Case Report

Treatment methods

Miniscalpelacupuncture

Prior to treatment, the patients were provided with comprehensive information about the procedure, and patients who agreed to the procedure were treated with miniscalpel acupuncture. Following the first treatment, subsequent treatment sessions were conducted at intervals of 5-8 days. The treatment interval was adjusted according to the patients’ symptoms and conditions.

To prevent infection, the practitioner wore sterilized gloves and a mask, and the treatment area was sterilized with betadine. The miniscalpel acupuncture points were: LI14, LI15, LI16, TE14, TE15, SI10, SI12, SI13, GB21, LU01, LU02 and tender points of the rotator cuff. The procedurewas performed in the recumbent position.Sterilized, disposable miniscalpels (0.5 mm × 50 mm; DongBang Acupuncture Inc., Korea) were used. The miniscalpel was inserted parallel to the nearby muscle and ligaments, at a depth of 20-40 mm, and the adhered soft tissue was peeled and the miniscalpe lpulled out. After the procedure, the patient was informed about possible side effects such as temporary discomfort, hemorrhage, dizziness, cold sweat, and palpitation. The miniscalpel acupuncture was performed by a Korean medicine doctor with over 2 years of clinical practice (Table 1).

Table 1.

Miniscalpel Acupuncture Details Based on the STRICTA 2010 Checklist [11].

Acupuncture

Acupuncture was performed once every day during the hospital stay, and the needle retention time was approximately 30 minutes. Sterilized, disposable needles (0.25 mm × 40 mm; DongBang Acupuncture Inc., Korea) were used. The acupuncture points were: Shinkwan (Dong’s acupuncture), ST40 of the normal side, and LI11, SI03, TE03 of the affected side.

Herbal medicine treatment

Seokyung decoction was prescribed to both patients from October 22. In Case 1, the medicine was changed to Kaegyeolseokyung decoction on October 24 and maintained until discharge day on November 17. In Case 2, Seokyung decoction was maintained during the hospital stay. The medicine was taken 3 times a day (Table 2).

Table 2.

Composition of Herbal Medicine.

Case 1

Patient

Song00, F/61

Chief complaint

Right shoulder pain and ROM restriction

Onset

February 2018

Past history

Left RCT, calcific tendinitis- 2012 op.

Present illness

Shoulder pain occurred whilst playing tennis in February 2018. The patient did not receive medical treatment and rested at home for 2 months. As the pain worsened, the patient sought medical treatment at a local hospital and was diagnosed with RCT using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The patient received a steroid injection in her right armand she underwent physical therapy for 3 months , but showed no improvement in symptoms. On August 10, the patient underwent arthroscopic surgeryat a local hospital. After the surgery, shoulder pain and ROM restriction persisted despite rehabilitation. On August 24, the patient was admitted to local Korean medicine hospital, and was treated with herbal medicine, acupuncture, and rehabilitation for a month, without significant improvement. She visited the Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Dong-Eui University Korean Medicine Hospital on October 22, 2018.

Symptoms of first-visit

The pain, which was rated as a VAS score 4, occurred around the rotator cuff, in a stable state. The pain increased to a VAS score 8 when the right arm was pressed, flexed, abducted and raised above the head, and when the arm was rotated internally and moved backward (ROM: flexion 100°, extension 10°, abduction 90°, adduction 10°, internal rotation 10°, external rotation 10°).

Radiological findings

The MRI of the patient’s shoulder was taken on August 7, 2018 at a local hospital. The finding was a partial tear of the supraspinatus and infraspinatus (Fig. 1).

Fig. 1.

Shoulder MRI of Case 1. (A) Axial, (B) Coronal. MRI, magnetic resonance imaging.

Treatment progress

The shoulder pain, which was a VAS score 4 in a stable state, disappeared after the 3rd miniscalpel acupuncture treatment. Furthermore, pain on movement of the arm decreased from a VAS score 8 to a VAS score 3, and shoulder ROM improved (Table 3), so it became possible for her arm to flex, abduct and raise above the head, and rotate internally and move backward.

Table 3.

Progress in the Treatment of Case 1.

Case 2

Patient

Yu 00, F/61

Chief complaint

Right shoulder pain and ROM restriction

Onset

December 2017

Past history

Non specific

Present illness

Shoulder pain occurred during exercising in December 2017. The patient did not receive medical treatment and the pain persisted. On April 2018, the patient was diagnosed with RCT using an MRI at a local hospital, and underwent arthroscopic surgery. However, the ROM of the shoulder joint worsened whilst wearing the shoulder brace. The patient received rehabilitation for 5 months, but no significant improvement was seen. She visited the Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, Dong-Eui University Korean Medicine Hospital on October 22, 2018.

Symptoms of first-visit

The pain which was rated as a VAS score 2, occurred around the greater tuberosity of the humerus, acromion, and acromioclavicular joint in a stable state. Pain increased to a VAS score 8 whilst exercising to the maximum range of the shoulder (ROM: flexion 100°, extension 30°, abduction 90°, adduction 40°, internal rotation 40°, external rotation 40°).

Radiological findings

An MRI of the shoulder was taken on April 26, 2018 at a local hospital. The findings were a full-thickness tear with a Grade 1 retraction of the supraspinatus, mid to posterior portion, and a low-grade articular surface partial-thickness tear of the infraspinatus, inferior portion (Fig. 2).

Fig. 2.

Shoulder MRI of Case 2. (A) Axial, (B) coronal. MRI, magnetic resonance imaging.

Treatment progress

Shoulder pain, which was rated as a VAS score 2 in the stable state and a VAS score 8 during shoulder movement at the first-visit, disappeared. In addition, shoulder ROM improved from flexion 100° to 170°, extension 30° to 45°, abduction 90° to 150°, adduction 40° to 40°, internal rotation 40° to 90°, and external rotation 40° to 70° (Table 4). After the treatment, the patient had normal function of the shoulder.

Table 4.

Progress in the Treatment of Case 2.

Discussion

The aim of RCT surgery is to stabilize the shoulder joint by placing the humeral head in the center of the joint, thereby facilitating the restoration of normal function to the shoulder. The larger the tear size, the more difficult it is to manage symptoms with conservative treatment. In addition, over time, the tear size increases and tissue regression often occurs. Even after the surgical procedure, it is often difficult to move, and pain is experienced [12] so appropriate rehabilitation after surgery is needed. Approximately 6 months of rehabilitation is recommended to restore normal function to the shoulder. Korean medical treatment may improve the efficiency of rehabilitation and help restore function to the shoulder.

The postoperative rehabilitation protocol for RCT is divided into 3 stages. The goal of Stage 1 is to control pain using a shoulder brace and medication for approximately 6 weeks, according to the severity of the tear, and to recover the shoulder ROM with 140° flexion, 40° external rotation, and 60° abduction by passive joint movement. The aim of Stage 2 (6-12 weeks after surgery) is to remove the shoulder brace, and to improve the shoulder ROM to 160° flexion, 60° external rotation and 90° abduction with active assistance, or when active joint movement is performed. At Stage 3 (4-6 months after surgery), the aim is restoring ROM to the same degree as the contralateral side, and strengthening the rotator cuff with passive joint motion, active assistance, and active joint motion, without shoulder joint pain or tenderness [2,13].

The patients in this study were at Stage 3 of the postoperative rehabilitation protocol for RCT. However, both patients complained of ROM limitation and shoulder pain, and despite continuous rehabilitation treatment, neither patient had passed Stage 1 of the postoperative rehabilitation protocol.

Miniscalpel acupuncture alleviates dysfunction by exfoliating adhesion and scarring between soft tissues. In addition, pain can be controlled by removing tension and pressure on the lesion tissue. Also, it has the advantage of improving circulation of the blood to the lesion tissue, and thus the speed of recovery at the site oftreatment [14,15]. In this study, the miniscalpel acupuncture points were the internal and external portions of the infraspinous region of scapula, where the rotator cuff originates, and the tender points of the supraspinous fossa, TE14, TE15, SI10, SI12, SI13 and GB21. The anterior, middle and posterior parts of the deltoid near the humerus, where the rotation cuff is inserted, LI14, LI15 and LI16 were treated. In addition, LU01 and LU02 were used to treat the anterior tender points of the pectoralis major, pectoralis minor, and subclavicular region.

In Case 1, the shoulder pain, which was a VAS score 4 in a stable state, disappeared, and pain during movement of the armdecreased from a VAS score 8 to a VAS score 3. Furthermore, shoulder ROM improved from flexion 100° to 160°, extension 10° to 30°, abduction 90° to 130°, adduction 10° to 40°, internal rotation 10° to 50°, and external rotation 10° to 50°. The patient complained of severe shoulder pain and ROM limitations when the right arm was internally rotated, it was impossible to position her arms backward. After the treatment, it became possible for her to grasp both hands behind her back. In Case 2, shoulder pain, which was rated as a VAS score 2 in the stable state and a VAS score 8 during shoulder movement at the first-visit, disappeared, and shoulder ROM recovered from flexion 100°, extension 30°, abduction 90°, adduction 40°, internal rotation 40°, and external rotation 40° to the normal range after treatment.

In this study, Korean medical treatment including miniscalpel acupuncture may have had positive clinical effects on pain relief and recovery of shoulder ROM after RCT surgery. However, because we observed only 2 cases in this study, the conclusion of this study cannot be generalized. Further, this study had some limitations, one of which was that other assessment tools had to be used to measure shoulder disability, such as shoulder pain and disability index, for more systemic evaluationin addition to VAS and ROM. Another limitation is that there was no control group in this study, and therefore comparison with other treatment tools could not be done. In the future, systematically-designed large scale randomized controlled trials should be conducted to study the effects of miniscalpel acupuncture after RCT surgery.

Article information Continued