The Comparative Study on the Effect of Fire Needling Therapy and General Acupuncture with Other Korean Traditional Medical Treatment for the Patient with Lumbar Herniated Intervertebral Disc: A Randomized Assessor Blinded Two Arm Trial

Article information

Acupunct. 2015;32(4):29-36
1Department of Acupuncture & Moxibustion Medicine, Chungju Hospital of Traditional Korean Medicine, Semyung University
*Corresponding author: Department of Acupuncture & Moxibustion Medicine, Chungju Hospital of Traditional Korean Medicine, Semyung University, 63, Sangbang 4-gil, Chungju-si, Chungcheongbuk-do 27429, Republic of Korea, Tel: +82-43-841-1738, E-mail: leetaeho0331@hanmail.net

This study was supported by Semyung University Research Grant of 2014.

Received 2015 October 28; Revised 2015 November 27; Accepted 2015 December 01.

Abstract

Objectives:

The purpose of this study is to compare the efficacy of fire needling therapy and general acupuncture for the patient with lumbar herniated intervertebral disc.

Methods:

We observed 20 lumbar herniated intervertebral disc patients from March, 2014 to October, 2015. This study was randomized and assessor blinded. The patients were divided into two groups: one group(group A) was treated by general acupuncture only, and the other group(group B) was treated by fire needling therapy and general acupuncture We evaluated the treatment effect experienced by each group using the visual analogue scale(VAS) and Oswestry disability index(ODI).

Results:

  1. In group A VAS and ODI from before treatment to treatment 4, 8, 12, 16 were significantly improved in statistics.

  2. In group B. VAS from before treatment to treatment 4, 8, 12, 16 was significantly improved but ODI was significantly improved in statistics only from before treatment to treatment 12, not in treatment 4, 8, 16.

  3. As a result of comparisons between group A and B, there were no statistical significance in VAS and ODI.

Conclusions:

This study was not able to determine statistical significance between the group treated by general acupuncture only and the group treated by fire needling therapy and general acupuncture so further studies are required in the future.

Sex and Age Distribution in Patients with Lumbar HIVD

Changes of VAS and ODI from Before Treatment to Treatment 4, 8, 12, 16

Comparisons of VAS and ODI from Before Treatment to Treatment 4, 8, 12, 16 between Two Groups

References

1. The Korean Orthopaedic Association. Orthopaedics 6th edth ed. Seoul: Choishineuihaksa; 2006. p. 617–30.
2. Park CY, Moon JH. Rehabilitation Medicine Seoul: Hanmibook; 2008. p. 908.
3. Suk SI. Spinal Surgery Seoul: Choishineuihaksa; 2004. p. 218–9.
4. Song BK. Study on the Conservative Treatment of Herniated Lumbar Intervertebral Disc. J Korean Oriental Med 1995;16(2):62–78.
5. Sarwark JF. Essentials of Musculoskeletal Care 4th edth ed. Seoul: Panmun; 2013. p. 660.
6. Hwang GC. A Clinical Study of Low Back Pain Following Lumbar Disc Surgery. Inje Medical Journal 1997;18(1):19–29.
7. Cho HJ, Sul JU, Shin MS. Research Trends on the Treatment of Lumbar Herniated Intervertebral Disc in Korean Medicine. Korean J Acupunct 2012;29(4):501–18.
8. We JS, Won SH, Hwang JS, et al. The Comparison of Effectiveness between Acupuncture and Its Cotreatment with Direct Moxibustion to Low Back Pain Patient. The Acupuncture 2004;21(60):221–31.
9. Kim MS, Park JY, Choi YJ, et al. Clinical Effects of Indirect Moxibustion Treatment with General Acupuncture on HIVD Patients in Comparison with General Acupuncture Only. The Acupuncture 2011;28(1):66–75.
10. Lee HS, Park JB, Seo JC, Park HJ, Lee HJ. Standards for Reporting Interventions in Controlled Trials of Acupuncture: The STRICTA Recommendations. The Acupuncture 2002;19(6):134–54.
11. Korean Acupuncture & Moxibustion Medicine Society. The Acupuncture and Moxibustion Medicine Gyeonggi: Jipmoondang; 2012. p. 144–6.
12. Fairbank JC, Couper J, Davies JB, O’Brien JP. The Oswestry Low Back Pain Disability Questionnaire. Physiotherapy 1980;66(8):271–3.
13. The Society of Korean Medicine Rehabilitation. Korean Rehabilitation Medicine 2nd edth ed. Seoul: Koonja; 2005. p. 59–61.
14. Kim SN, Kim SC, Choi HK, et al. Clinical Study on Effect of Scolopendrid Aquacupuncture classified by the Type of Lumabr Disc Herniation. The Acupuncture 2004;21(5):79–99.
15. An SS, Heo DS. The Clinical Effects of Heating-Conduction Acupuncture Therapy for Anterior Talofibular and Calcaneofibular Ligament Injury Induced by Acute Ankle Sprain. JORM 2010;20(3):119–29.

Article information Continued

Table 1

Sex and Age Distribution in Patients with Lumbar HIVD

Group A Group B p-value
N* Before Treatment 10 10
Treatment 4 10 10
Treatment 8 8 10
Treatment 12 7 10
Treatment 16 7 8
Sex(male / female) 4 / 6 2 / 8
Age 45.30±8.79 41.30±10.51 0.363
*

Number of patients

Group A: group treated with general acupuncture only

Group B: group treated with fire needling therapy and general acupuncture

Values are represented as mean±standard deviation.

p-value<0.05 by Mann-Whitney U test

Table 2

Changes of VAS and ODI from Before Treatment to Treatment 4, 8, 12, 16

Group A Before Treatment (N* = 10) Treatment 4 (N* = 10) Treatment 8 (N* = 8) Treatment 12 (N* = 7) Treatment 16 (N* = 7)
VAS 69.70±15.41 48.00±11.30 35.63±13.06 31.29±15.48 33.57±27.40
p-value 0.005 0.012 0.018 0.028
ODI 24.00±7.48 21.60±7.06 20.50±5.45 19.57±6.48 17.00±7.51
p-value 0.011 0.018 0.018 0.017
Group B Before Treatment (N* = 10) Treatment 4 (N* = 10) Treatment 8 (N* = 8) Treatment 12 (N* = 7) Treatment 16 (N* = 7)
VAS 68.10±13.66 49.50±13.38 38.70±18.87 28.00±20.52 26.75±21.62
p-value 0.012 0.007 0.007 0.012
ODI 20.10±7.02 16.70±5.79 16.00±6.73 14.80±7.16 15.63±6.02
p-value 0.089 0.075 0.028 0.068
*

Number of patients

Group A: group treated with general acupuncture only

Group B: group treated with fire needling therapy and general acupuncture

VAS: Visual Analogue Scale

ODI: Oswestry Disability Index

Values are represented as mean±standard deviation.

p-value <0.05 by Wilcoxon signed rank test

Table 3

Comparisons of VAS and ODI from Before Treatment to Treatment 4, 8, 12, 16 between Two Groups

Group A Group B p-value
Before Treatment ~Treatment 4 N* = 10 N* = 10
VAS 21.70±12.07 18.60±20.95 0.690
ODI 2.40±2.55 3.40±5.75 0.622
Before Treatment ~Treatment 8 N* = 8 N* = 10
VAS 37.50±15.14 29.40±23.41 0.411
ODI 5.38±3.93 4.10±7.45 0.668
Before Treatment ~Treatment 12 N* = 7 N* = 10
VAS 39.29±14.59 40.10±23.63 0.937
ODI 6.14±4.95 5.30±8.04 0.810
Before Treatment ~Treatment 16 N* = 7 N* = 8
VAS 37.00±27.20 39.88±25.67 0.837
ODI 8.71 ±7.99 2.75±3.81 0.082
*

Number of patients

Group A: group treated with general acupuncture only

Group B: group treated with fire needling therapy and general acupuncture

VAS: Visual Analogue Scale

ODI: Oswestry Disability Index

Values are represented as mean±standard deviation.

p-value <0.05 by independent samples t-test